Computer Hardware

This page gives a quite basic description of several issues related to computer hardware. Firstly there is the description of which brands can be relied upon, according to my personal experience. This can be taken as an advice to building your own system, on which a short description is given. After which some guidelines on debugging HW problems are provided, since a structured approach often leads to finding the evil quickly.

Most of the information on these pages is based on personal experience, related to having dealt with quite a lot of problems myself (and not giving up on them) resulting in getting more and more experienced. The intention is not to provide full details of which components exactly to use to built your system, since that is what computer magazines are good for (The one I rely on is called C't and is available in Dutch and German), but also online you can find a lot of information (see links in right column).

Advice on HW components

This section will describe which brands are classified as better in the component world and what experience I have with them. Mind you that even the manufacturers that are known as good, can have a bad lot or series. It is therefore a good idea not to buy the very first product of the line unless you are freaky and confident that you're going to find the problem anyway.

Motherboard

The motherboard connects it all together and is the basis for your system, therefore it is quite important in making a good decision here. As a "mother" for all the other components, there ar some components used to connect everything together, the North and Southbridge. There are several manufacturers making these bridge chips (called chipset): Intel, VIA, Nvidia & ATI. The former mainly focus on chipsets for Intel processors, the latter more on AMD processors.

These chipsets are of increasing importance, since they often contain everything which is offered on-board (ethernet, firewire, usb, audio, etc.). The choice of chipset will relate to the processor of choice, and also determine the rest of the machines components (memory, graphics card and so on).

The most famous brand on motherboards for desktop systems is probably ASUS. However it is often worth shopping around, and check the other brands: AOpen, Abit, EPoX, Gigabyte, MSI & Intel. For server machines (machines which have a high system demand 24/7) Intel, Supermicro & Tyan should be considered.

Processor

The choice of this is closely related to the motherboard and memory bandwidth. There are two major brands, Intel and AMD, where the latter is sometimes referred to as the underdog. Personally I prefer the former, mainly because I've experienced AMDs burning out, but that should be past, since their latter products also have temperature management.

Processor marketing has long been focussing on only the speed as important factor, however the complete architecture is of importance. Now I want go into detail, but in general the more cache, the higher the speed of processor and memory bus, the better. Since all these factors are of importance, intel has changed its processor names to numbers, which represent, speed as well as cache size and so on. AMD has been marketing its processors for a while by naming them according to which intel processor they best compare with, though the actual speed of those AMDs is lower.

Currently there are a few major trends, the first one is the move towards 64 bit. On the processor side 64 bit is quite well supported now.

A second trend is the move towards multi-core processors, which is one of the few ways to increase processor performance or shall I say the how they market the current "improvements" (trust me I know). One of the first signs of that was intel's hyperthreading, which presents the processor as two processors to the OS. After that a whole range of dual core and quad core processors came along. Generally a dual core can still help in making your machine more responsive if you perform multiple tasks simultaneously (that would also include a virus-scanner running in the background). Though during normal home and office use, you would rarely need 4 processors.

Concerning speed, I used to prefer the highest speed one, but that changed, since you have to know that only a speed improvement of 20 % or more is noticeable to you as a user. Secondly, the price gap between the highest speed processor and the second fastests is often quite large, therefore the latter is often the better choice.

Memory

If there's one field where the manufacturers have managed to confuse the user, then this is probably the one, since even I lost it at some point ! The whole struggle started with RAMBUS, for which the current Pentium 4 was designed, but although it was a nice technology, it did not take of due to the high price. So the world moved another way, namely from SRAM, with different bus-speeds, towards DDR, DDR2, DDR3 and maybe soon more of these nice acronyms. Within each of these DDR-technologies you then still have different speeds. So for example there is DDR266 (PC2100) and DDR333 (PC2700) for DDR memory and similarly for the DDR2 and DDR3 series. Normally a memory of a particular type, say DDR3 with a higher clock-speed will work in slots at a lower clock-speed. The other way around is the more risky way of doing things.

The DDR2 technology is a dual channel memory, which means that you achieve a more optimal performance by using them in dual channel mode. To do so you need two identical memory modules (in capacity) and slot them in the appropriate slots of the motherboard. They actually sell sets of memory that were produced together for this purpose, so better to buy them like that. Similar applies to DDR3, which has tripple channel.

Since the memory range has become so large it is better to check the compatibility list of the motherboard that you intend to buy.

Although the speed is of particular importance, the reliability is even more important. It is therefore recommended not to by cheap memory, but go for reliable brands like Crucial, Kingston, Corsair. That is taking you don't use the memory with error correction, which you would commonly find in server type machines.

Graphics

In relation to graphics, there are two main manufacturers: ATI and Nvidea, and a third smaller one: Maxtor. The first two produce mainly chipsets, which are then put onto graphics accelerator boards by different manufacturers, e.g. asustek, gainward, ... .

Your choice in this area should be related to what graphics processing you are intended to do. In some cases you might simply want to stick to the on-board graphics of your motherboard, but don't expect all to much from this. For higher performance graphics you normally need to use a separate graphics card.

These days the way to connect these graphics cards to the motherboard is PCI-Express x16, meaning that is uses 16 normal PCI-Express channels.

The outputs on most current graphics cards also supports two monitors and sometimes an additional S-video or composite output. The outputs for monitors are either VGA or DVI-D outputs. The former supports the older analogue CRTs and the first series of LCDs als had such inputs. These days it is more common to use DVI, either in single or dual link (same type of connector, but the latter has more pins present). The difference between these two types of DVI is that they handle a different maximum resolution, namely 1920x1200 and 2560x1600 respectively.

Currently there is an uprise of HDMI also on graphical cards as a connector, although originally developed for TVs. The main reason being that for blu-ray you need the HDCP (copyright protection standard) which is standard with HDMI, but not standard on DVI. In the future we shall also see displayport connectors comming (they look very similar to HDMI, but are again designed for the computer world).

Harddrive

The topic of hard-drives is a though one, since I have not had many reliable drives in my life. I was recently talking to some ICT people and asked their opinion on which brand to buy, they basically replied: "It doesn't make a difference which brand you buy, they all last for a couple of years and fail.". Having said that you can only hope that your waranty is for longer than this period, but then again you still have all the hassle.

Personal experience, I have had several brands. Seagate, Maxtor and Western Digital all seemed fairly reliable. The IBM (Hitachi) desktop-drives I had only lasted for a couple of years or even less. They suddenly fail and that's it, however I have always been able to extract my data, so they don't fail to horribly, but still enough to throw them after the recovery. On laptop-drives they are known as the better brand, though mine also failed after about 3 years, at which point I managed to get it back up again ... though did not quite trust it anymore.

Concerning size, if you don't have any specific size requirement, then the best approach is to calculate the price per size unit (MB. GB, TB). Normally the largest and smallest drive are not really worth their money.

Due to this high failure rate, I therefore advice you to buy and or use a decent backup strategy. Mind you that RAID cannot really be seen as a backup strategy. While we are on the topic of RAID, I would advise type 1, 5 or 6. These days many motherboards come with raid controllers, which are normally fine for windows users. If you intend to use the raid from linux, then you better search for a decent hardware raid controller. If you only use linux then you can also choose for a software raid, but then I would advies you to write a script to check that raid is still working.

CD/DVD/Blu-Ray drive

The times of pure CD-drives is long gone, even DVD is becoming old days. We are slowly moving towards Blu-ray for sure now, since HD-DVD has given up the battle.

A large number of acronyms are used in relation to CD, DVD as well as Blu-ray, so here for some clarification. Firstly, there is the distinction between normal Writeable (W) and ReWriteable (RW) disks, their name should be self-explanatory. For DVD, there is an additional distinction in using either a "-" (DVD-R, DVD-RW) or a "+" (DVD+R, DVD+RW). This indicates the writing standard. The official standard is actually the "-"-one, however these days nearly all burners and readers handle both without problems. Just be aware of the difference and that this can cause problems. One type of disks is also more expensive than the other, so choose appropriately. Furthermore, in relation to DVD and Blu-Ray you can still find an additiona lettre, namely "D" which stands for Double Layer. This means that the disk has 2 layers for recording, which clearly also (nearly) doubles the storage capacity.

Which brand of burner ? Well my personal preferrance goes out to Plextor, however I have had other brands too without problems. It might again be a good idea not to buy top of the range, since burners are designed only to last for a number of disks (don't worry its more than a couple of hundred), after which they write more and more errors on your disk, hence creating toasters. One trick to keep your burner working fine for longer is to keep it cool, so ensure decent airflow around it.

Concerning media for your burner, don't buy the cheapest, since they are quite often not worth their money at all other than becoming toasters. Try to find a good middle class product, and make sure they support the write speed you intend to use. It is also a good idea not to buy a large numbers of disks in one go, if you have not tried them before. You have to know that many brands selling disks are not the brands making them, and therefore the disks you buy next time might appear the same brand to you, but could come from a different manufacturer.

Case and Power Supply

Many people think that a case is only needed to make it look nice or safe, which is to some extend true. However if this leads to a decision of buying the cheapest solution, then you are likely to face problems. This has two reasons: 1) the case needs to have a good air-flow to ensure the system does not overheat; 2) the Power Supply Unit (PSU) comming with cheap cases is often a source to lots of problems.

These days many cases come with a large amount of fans and if you go to fancier cases, then you can install your PC nearly screwless. This feature is particularly interesting for servers or of you intend to change a lot of hardware quite often. In terms of cases there is no good or bad. Just buy whatever design you fancy and fits you requirements, the contents will determine much more anyway.

The PSU is the source of a lot of evil or good in your PC. It can be the reason to many problems for which no cause can be found, however, it often gets ignored. Believe me, a cheap PSU has caused me lots of frustration and only when it got replaced (after two years tearing out my hair wondering why my PC crashed on a nearly daily basis) I knew the importance of a good supply (ever since that same PC did not crash). As usual, the good stuff is not cheap. Now some brands which I would recommend, from personal experience, are: Antec & Enermax.

Keyboard, Mouse

Concerning keyboard and especially mouse, I have a specific preference for Logitech equipment. Simply because there are very few other real brands in this area and they are the best in my opinion. The only other real brands in this area are Trust and Microsoft. The latter already earns enough with their software, and since their software is a bit doubtfull, I prefer to stay away from their hardware.

Since I used to get pain in my wrists while typing I took the plunge and tried a natural/ergonomic keyboard which actually solved that problem for me. I do admit it might be good to try before you buy, since many people don't like it at all. My preferred mouse is cordless and has as many buttons as possible, which allows me to do a lot with my mouse only. Though due to RSI, I have recently also extended my collection of ergonimic pen-type like mice. My favorites in this category come from Wow-pen, besides the Toshiba e-pen.

Screen

CRT monitors these days are as good as ruled out, except for people that work in the graphics industry and some gamers keen on large resolutions, high refresh rates and large screens. If you don't belong to this category, then an LCD is a better option since CRTs are quite power hungry and need replacement after a number of years to maintain optimal colours.

Having said that, LCDs are in addition also better for the eyes. They are also said to last longer, though on average it is the backlight that fails first. Hence, there are now more and more screens with LED backlighting, of which there are two types. The ones with white LEDs and the ones with RGB LEDs. The latter have the best colour representation, since their White is really white light with a full spectrum. At this point they are therefore mainly found in professional panels for graphical editing. The additional benefit of LED backlighting is that they consume less power. Oh, and don't worry they do tell you which backlighting they use, so if not mentioned, then you can assume it is standard stuff.

Furthermore, I would advice for your screen to have a digital interface, it being DVI or HDMI. Since panels are digital it is better if you can also connect them to your computer with a digital interface (that is clearly taking your computer supports this).

LCDs come in many different flavours and sizes, one thing to look at is the size of screen you want and the resolution it offers. Some people prefer large resolutions since it fits a lot on a screen, other prefer things (mainly fonts) to look a bit larger, which means they should choose a smaller resolution on a large screen.

Concerning brands for buying a screen. Philips and Sony where always big in producing CRT screens, but jumped onto the LCD wagon way to late. There is only Samsung and LG producing the panels themselves, all others are only designing the electronics around the panel and casing them.

 

Composing your machine

In this section I want describe exact components, since that changes to frequently. The best way to perform your final check is to either ask a friend or relative who knows about these things or post in a newsgroup. In the latter case, mention all details and ask your specific question, like: "Will this be compatible ?", "Are there any problems with this combination ?", ... .

Oh, if you intend to built you own system, then please make sure you know what you're doing. These days there is a lot of information available on the web, but also your manuals should be helpful (so read them!). Alternatively you can get your machine built at the local computer shop, which they will gladly do for you in return for money obviously. At this point I would like to make a remark that in relation to the many shops around there are few that really know their stuff (trust me I had trouble finding decent shops although there are plenty around), so try to ask around to people who know on where to go.

The path of combining different components into one machine has never been completely flat, but some web-sites of component shops now offer a guided combining of their components. Please bear in mind that a machine should be bought with a particular set of functions in mind and can then be specialised towards these. If you want to do everything or have enough money then you might simply buy top of the range of everything, which will last a bit longer, but in general a machine is up-to-date for around 3 to 4 years. Quite likely your requirements have changed in that period and you might want to get something new, so decide on your budget appropriately.

 

How to debug HW problems

This section will deal with two types of problems: 1) your machine is built but does not work; 2) the machine is working, but there is something wrong. The second type of problem is probably related to either a driver, a compatibility problem or hardware failure of some minor type. This second type is often the hardest to discover, especially if you cannot identify specific actions that cause the system to fail.

Please do bear in mind that for many problems, google is your friend, since a good description of your problem will often lead to people with the same problem and hopefully a solution.

Get your machine working

If you boot your machine, then the motherboard checks itself, called POST (Power On Self Test). Normally your system beeps once shortly if everything is alright, any other combination indicates the detected problem. Further explanation on these different codes can be found e.g. here. Sometimes these codes can indicate the problem, if not then a structured approach, e.g. the one as described below have to be followed to detect the evil.

First things first, so check that your motherboard and PC get power. Starting with the leads to the PC and the lead from PSU to motherboard. Quite often the motherboard will have a led indicating it either has power or not. If there is no power, then you are likely to have a power supply problem, or a motherboard problem. If there is power according to the motherboard and you press the button but nothing happens, then there are several possible causes: 1) the PSU is not powerfull enough (could also be due to the fact that it is partly broken); 2) some component does not work.

If your machine did behave normally before, then the most likely reason is the PSU. So check that one, by either taking a sufficiently powerfull one from another PC or simply replace it and try again. It is perfectly possible that the PSU can supply the current for stand-by, but not cope with the peak current demanded during start-up.

In case you just composed your machine and it is not booting, then I would propose you to check the individual components. So strip all components from your motherboard, except for the processor. Press the button and see whether your machine beeps more than once shortly. This indicates that the motherboard notices the lack of certain components (memory, graphics card, ...). Meanwhile check that the processor fan is running, since you don't want to burn that thing. If not, then is the cable connected. Then check the power for the fan. If nothing works, then your problem might be due to PSU, motherboard or processor. Since each component is generally tested before leaving the factory, it is likely tthat you have a problem with the combination of components or one has become faulty.

If this test was successfull, then add components one by one, go in order of adding: memory, graphics card, hard-drives, etc.. Each time try to boot and check the number of beeps and whether you start getting something on the screen. If the problem starts when you connect a particular component, then you should check that component and its connectors.

If this strategy does not help, and you can boot, but still run into problems, then a good advice is to disable the on-board components one by one till you find the faulty one.

Your machine works, but ...

At this stage, you can install your OS, as well as all relevant drivers. Note that sometimes you need a driver for your IDE or SATA controller during installation to get the system installed. After having done this, you have a working but unstable system ? If your machine crashes regularly, then try to see whether there are particular actions that cause it to fail, in which case you need to check any hardware and drivers related to this action. E.g.: your machine always crashes after you plug in a certain USB device. This can have several reasons, either the device is faulty, the driver has a problem or there is a compatibility issue with other hardware on the same machine. More about the latter one in a while. The device can obviously be tested by connecting it to another machine, whereas for the driver you should try to get hold of the latest or another version than the current one and try with that version. If neither of these approaches help, then there might be a more serious compatibility problem. So, get yourself onto google and hunt the evil.

One way to find out compatibility problems is to use the components name for a search and see if any newsgroup related articles come up and also contain another component in your machine. If yes, then you are one step closer to a possible solution. If no then it might be a good idea to e.g. swap use a different connector for particular components. This is based on the idea that interrupts and some drivers sometimes interact badly in particular combinations.

If all of this did not help, or you get random crashes, then it becomes slightly harder to find the problem. However now one of your first checks should actually be your power-supply, especially if you did not buy a decent one.

 

Related links: